Dismiss Modal

Jeni A Shull Clayton, MD

Family Medicine, Lifestyle Medicine

Riverview Health

About Jeni A Shull Clayton, MD

Many of the chronic conditions family medicine physicians encounter are linked to the way patients eat, move and deal with stress. Jeni Clayton, MD, MPH, uses lifestyle medicine as the foundation for treatment of chronic disease, with medications and medical interventions being used as necessary. Dr. Clayton encourages and empowers patients to live healthier lives by addressing nutrition, physical activity, sleep, stress management and the avoidance of harmful substances. 

Dr. Clayton attended medical school at Indiana University School of Medicine. She completed her residencies at Loma Linda University in California, and her fellowship in Lifestyle Medicine at Black Hills Health and Education Center in South Dakota. She is board-certified in family medicine, preventive medicine and lifestyle medicine. Dr. Clayton grew up in northern Indiana and enjoys hiking, traveling and gardening. 

Clinical Interest

  • International travel medicine

  • Lifestyle medicine

  • Pediatrics

  • Preventive medicine

  • Tobacco cessation

  • Vaccine recommendations


“I chose family medicine for the opportunity to work with adults and children. I chose preventive and lifestyle medicine because 80 percent of the chronic conditions we treat in medicine are tied to how we eat, move and deal with stress. I love working with patients and empowering them through lifestyle changes and medical treatments to live healthy lives. ”

Schedule an appointment

Locations

Prairie Lakes Family Medicine

14540 Prairie Lakes Blvd. N, Suite 102
Noblesville, IN 46060-4370

View hours
Monday
7:00am - 5:00pm
Tuesday
7:00am - 5:00pm
Wednesday
7:00am - 5:00pm
Thursday
7:00am - 5:00pm
Friday
7:00am - 5:00pm
Prairie Lakes Family Medicine

Education & Certifications

Education

Medical School:
Indiana University School of Medicine

Fellowship:
Black Hills Health and Education Center

Board Certifications

American Board of of Family Medicine

American Board of of Preventive Medicine

Provider Ratings

4.9 out of 5

(230 ratings)

The following ratings and reviews are based on verified feedback collected from independently administered patient experience surveys. The ratings and comments submitted by patients reflect their own views and opinions. We remove any personal health information to protect privacy and filter out comments that aren't related to the care provided. Not all ratings are converted to comments.

AI Summary

Patients consistently praise Dr. Clayton for being attentive, caring, and thorough; many note she listens, explains options clearly, and never rushes visits. Staff professionalism, friendliness, and effective communication are repeatedly highlighted. Several comments appreciate whole-person care (diet, exercise, mental health) and successful problem-solving during exams. Overall sentiment is highly positive with trust in clinical competence and compassionate care across visits.

Patient Comments

04/28/2026

Dr Clayton took the time to answer all my questions to my satisfaction. She is great!

04/23/2026

I'm very happy to have this hospital All teams are very good and helpful

04/22/2026

I always have a good time with m y doctor and staff. I just had a B12 shot. I AM GOOD FOR THE MONTH.

04/21/2026

Professional yet very caring. You leave feeling well taken care of.

04/20/2026

Love the staff always positive and polite

04/20/2026

She’s thorough, listens well, and cares about my health.

04/20/2026

Everything is run efficiently and Dr Clayton is very nice and extremely knowledgeable. When I’ve had to see one of the PAs or nurse practitioners, I was always very happy with their care and concern.

04/20/2026

They are always courteous, professional and friendly. Response time is good. Which is comforting especially when you are sick or anxious about a health concern

04/20/2026

Treated fantastic

03/27/2026

Everything went smoothly and wasn't any thing to complain about.

03/20/2026

Experienced and caring!

03/17/2026

Dr. Clayton always takes time to understand all my concerns.

03/16/2026

Dr. Clayton is a very understanding doctor. Very easy to talk to would highly recommend.

03/16/2026

Everyone was professional and very caring. [PHI redacted]

03/16/2026

I’m a fan and satisfied patient of Dr Clayton’s

03/16/2026

Excellent care and interest in overall patient wellness. Use of plain language when giving care instructions that are easy to understand. Cares about mom as a person not just a patient visit. Highly recommend.

03/16/2026

The whole staff including front office, nurses, medical assistants, and physicians especially Dr. Clayton are wonderful.

02/20/2026

Always pleased with my care at Prairie Lakes Family Medicine. Everyone from check in, person taking me to exam room, taking my vitals, checking my med list and getting me ready to see Dr Clayton are very kind and professional. Dr Clayton listens to my issues, discusses options and gives me her recommendations. I never feel rushed.I would recommend Dr Clayton and Prairie Lakes Family Medicine to anyone wanting a family practice physician.

02/20/2026

Dr Clayton is the best

02/18/2026

Dr Clayton listens, she’s thorough, patient & kind.

02/17/2026

I would recommend Dr Clayton to anyone looking for a family Dr

02/13/2026

Awesome Doctor. Staff and the lab personnel.

02/11/2026

Appreciated the questions and examine. Issues were explained well by Dr Clayton.

02/06/2026

There is no better PCP then DR Clayton she is the best of the best.

02/04/2026

No complaints. She's a good doctor!

02/04/2026

Doctor and staff are professional, nice and friendly. I have no complaints.

01/31/2026

The staff is very helpful.

01/31/2026

When I have physicals with my IU Health doctor it was rushed and only a standard check up and I couldn’t bring up any of my health concerns and was told to make another appointment for any health concerns. Dr Clayton went over everything thoroughly and was in no rush!!

01/30/2026

I found this office staff very knowledgeable, friendly & efficient from Dr. Clayton, the nursing staff, to the up front receptionists. I feel fortunate our newly formed paths have crossed. Thank you for your service!

01/23/2026

Dr Jeni is very personable and encouraging and really knows her stuff

01/22/2026

Dr. Clayton is an excellent physician.

01/20/2026

Dr. Clayton takes time to listen to her patients. She doesn't make them feel rushed. And addresses their concerns directly.

01/20/2026

Dr Clayton and her staff are very professional, caring, competent and knowledgeable. We have been with Riverview and Dr Clayton for over a year now, and we are very pleased having her as our primary care physician.

01/14/2026

Dr Clayton was able to figure out what was wrong with me and treated appropriately which relieved my pain. She always takes her time and answers all of my questions.

01/14/2026

Everyone is so pleasant and efficient.

01/10/2026

The team there always takes very good care of me doctors office staff nurse practitioners

01/09/2026

Dr Clayton is always attentive to my health concerns and this has been my experience no matter who I was seen by since I started going to Praire Lakes more than 20 years ago.

01/09/2026

Everyone friendly and helpful. Short wait time. Nurses and doctors take time to talk with you about your concerns. Thorough and informative conversation. Feel better about things when I leave. They relate to the patient.

01/07/2026

Dr Clayton and staff are very professional.

01/07/2026

Dr Clayton is very knowledgeable and caring. I appreciate everything she has done for me.

01/05/2026

Always do feel better after being seen at Prairie Lakes Family Medicine...the staff is very friendly and very professional... always put the patient first...

01/01/2026

Such a peaceful environment and Dr. C was wonderfully down to earth: caring, calm, and unrushed though I’m assuming she has a new patient time limit.

12/31/2025

Dr. Clayton is an excellent physician. She has provided me with great care. [name redacted to protect PHI]

12/30/2025

Got in quickly and Dr Clayton was great

12/30/2025

Everyone was respectful and professional!

12/30/2025

Dr. Clayton was a great listener and spent time with me answering my questions and making suggestions for positive change. I have great trust in her!

12/16/2025

Dr Clayton answered my questions & explained thugs to me well. She listens & takes my concerns seriously.

12/10/2025

The staff is excellent about communicating with me regarding my care with the doctors and my questions are always answered and I feel doctor Clayton and Dr. [ ] always addressed my concerns and take care of my health mentally and physically

12/10/2025

Dr. Clayton and her entire staff has been nothing but kind and professional every time I work with them. They always contact me back immediately and get these done in a timely matter. They are all nothing short of amazing. Thank you all from the bottom of my heart. [name redacted to protect PHI]

12/09/2025

Dr. Clayton is fantastic.

12/07/2025

Dr. Clayton is very caring and knowledgeable. She takes her valuable time to sit and talk with me if I have concerns.

12/05/2025

Good care.

12/02/2025

We always receive excellent care when we need it

12/02/2025

Lovely staff and great doc!

11/30/2025

Excellent staff. Dr Clayton is wonderful

11/29/2025

Dr. Clayton and her staff are always thoughtful and caring and I truly appreciate them!

11/26/2025

Dr. Clayton and the staff are friendly and very professional. They listen and provide great insight.

11/26/2025

I am very pleased with my care at Prairie LakesFamily Medicine. Minimal wait time for medical assistant and then Dr Clayton. Dr Clayton spends all the time I need ,with an exam and answering all my questions. I never feel rushed.I would recommend Prairie Lakes Family Medicine to anyone looking for a family physician.

11/26/2025

I feel so comfortable with Dr Clayton and her staff. She really does have my best interest at heart and listens to me.

11/26/2025

Dr Clayton listened to all my concerns and gave me options to address my health issues. Her and her staff were professional and pleasant to make the visit a great experience.

11/25/2025

Everyone in this office is friendly and courteous.

11/25/2025

Always friendly, and they listen to me, with any concerns. I’ve been going to Prairie Lakes since 1980. I have been treated by many physicians, I have no intention of leaving. You work with me, for my health.

11/12/2025

Dr Clayton is an amazing and caring doctor. I would recommend her to anyone who needed care.

11/12/2025

Dr Clayton is very thorough, takes time with me & I value her medical knowledge to get my health back.

11/11/2025

Everyone at this facility is kind and knows what they are doing.

11/11/2025

Love Dr. Clayton! She is a loving, caring and very through Doctor. God Bless

11/11/2025

At my age, I am extremely pleased with the care and concern that I get for my care from my physician!!!

11/07/2025

Staff is courteous and professional. Doctor is knowledgeable and very sensitive. Wait time is always very short.

11/07/2025

Discussed all past, current and future needs. Recommended restart Mental Health appointments.

11/04/2025

Dr Clayton is very kind, thorough, a great listener & patient. She’s is a great physician!

11/04/2025

Provider is very professional and compassionate as well as the staff.

10/28/2025

Always has time for extra questions. Never seems rushed.

10/24/2025

Dr. Clayton is very knowledgeable and competent. I would always recommend her without question.

10/22/2025

Dr. Clayton has been so kind and understanding. She takes her time with me, listening to my concerns and offering as many solutions as she can, always giving me the option to choose. If I am overwhelmed and not keeping up with things as I should, she simply encourages me and perhaps offers alternatives that better suit my lifestyle and never shames or belittles me.

10/22/2025

They are always friendly

10/22/2025

Dr. Clayton is the best doctor I’ve ever had. All support staff are terrific too. Great care.

10/17/2025

The staff listens and takes all time necessary to arrive at their results. I feel like I am in capable hands.

10/17/2025

Appreciate their care for the whole person and families. Chose Dr. Clayton specifically because of her approach addressing diet, exercise, healthy lifestyle first....and medications as a last resort. She is amazing!!!

10/15/2025

I felt very seen and heard during my visit.

10/14/2025

Dr. Clayton did a thorough job of examining me and thankfully corrected my misunderstanding of what I thought I was experiencing. I am grateful for her help.

10/14/2025

Dr. Clayton is thorough & addresses all my concerns, making me feel comfortable & heard.

10/14/2025

Everything goes smoothly from the time we enter the office until we leave

10/14/2025

Dr Clayton is great and so are her nurses. I’ve never had a negative experience with her. I’ve recommended one of my friends who is not happy with her Dr.

10/14/2025

From the CMA that took care of me to Dr Clayton who I am so pleased with, the visit was a good experience. Thank you ????

10/10/2025

Friendly and professional from check in through entire visit.

10/07/2025

Kind, professional and caring from entering to leaving.

10/07/2025

Great service. Nice staff.

10/01/2025

Dr. Clayton is absolutely wonderful.

09/23/2025

Dr. Clayton always takes time to listen to my concerns and I do not feel rushed in or out. I feel that all my questions are answered.

09/21/2025

Dr Clayton was thorough & actively listened to me. She immediately tried to get to what’s causing my symptoms instead of just trying to treat them. She explained things well & I never once felt rushed.

09/12/2025

Dr. Clinton listens to my concerns and tries to find solutions. She doesn't rush through my wellness check.

09/12/2025

Dr.Clayton is very kind, passionate, knowledgeable and listens.

09/09/2025

Dr Clayton was very attentive and spent time listening and offering helpful suggestions.

09/05/2025

It's always been a friendly place to go for your healthcare.

09/03/2025

Dr Clayton took time and answered my concerns
Show more